Chickenhawks ...

s-t-t at juno.com s-t-t at juno.com
Thu Oct 3 14:26:19 PDT 2002


Yoshie Furuhashi fwd'd:
> [...A chickenhawk is a term often applied to public persons -
> generally male - who (1) tend to advocate, or are fervent supporters
> of those who advocate, military solutions to political problems, and
> who have personally (2) declined to take advantage of a significant
> opportunity to serve in uniform during wartime....

Dennis Perrin responds:
> This "chickenhawk" critique is ridiculous and hypocritical, esp when
> coming from the left (and esp from those who've never worn the
> uniform themselves). What -- do you wish that W., Lott, Quayle, et al.,
> had volunteered to kill Vietnamese? If they had, would you respect
> them more when they called for war on Iraq? Bush senior is a combat
> vet, and I don't recall anyone who opposed the first Gulf War saying
> that, well, at least he served.
>
> There's plenty to critique in the current war cycle without going
> this simplistic route.

Yep, and as an argument it's fallacious. To be a nerd, it's an ad hominem (circumstantial, specifically tu quoque): attacking an arguer for inconsistency between their stance and their actions or other beliefs.

-- Shane

________________________________________________________________ GET INTERNET ACCESS FROM JUNO! Juno offers FREE or PREMIUM Internet access for less! Join Juno today! For your FREE software, visit: http://dl.www.juno.com/get/web/.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list