right of return

[Max B. Sawicky]

Moral considerations and solutions are touching
but irrelevant.  You have people on both sides
who will kill or die, notwithstanding universal
consistent moral considerations.  The answer to the
moral quandry is simple:  all the Jews should pick up
and move to Nebraska.  The real problem is
political:  how to achieve best possible solution.

You're a raging idealist!

mbs

So, it's perfectly fine to eliminate 75% of the Palestinian population 
(1948), and it's perfectly fine for every Jew in the world to have the 
right to "return" to Palestine, but the inhabitants of Palestine can go 
fuck themselves because otherwise they are denying the jews their state? A 
state won on the coattails of the British empire and maintained through 
support of the U.S. empire? Self-determination my ass!

Who decided that the right of jews to their own state is the highest moral 
imperative?

Joanna