A Duty to Disobey All Unlawful Orders

Steven McGraw stmcgraw at vt.edu
Tue Mar 18 21:26:08 PST 2003



>
>try reading what mark bennett actually wrote.
>
>now, i will agree with you that given that he chose _not_ to reiterate what
>he'd said--that the mil learned a lesson in nam and that is that they
>needed to produce a certain kind of soldier to fight in civil wars--belies
>that fact that it was merely a fig leaf for the attitude that both of
>us--you and I, steve--despise among some people on this list. nonetheless,
>it annoys the living piss out of me when people misread/read hastily.
>
>

You're right. I did what I always berate others for doing. I attacked an imaginary version of his argument rather than the argument itself. Apologies all around.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list