"You like being marginal, don't you? It gives you some weird sense of superiority."
Doug, your Carrol-bashing is compulsive. Carrol, like everyone one else on this list, simply states his opinion. Wrong, right, insightful, superficial, whatever. Why do you pick him out in particular for being a demagogue. To my ears, his tone and arguments do not sound appreciably different from anyone elses on the list.
C'mon...
Joanna