In my view, F's graetest work is Discipline and Punish, nominally about the history of punishment, but more generally about the mechaniism of bureaucratic control in the modern world. He starts out with an unforgetable discription of the horrible death of regicide, by way of making the point that back in the premodern world most people lived off the radar of the state altogether, no files, no dossiers, no lists,a nd that when you got on that radar, it was often to makea
spectacualr example of you. He then talks about the birth of the prison not as an example of progress and humanitarian reform, but as an instance of the needs of bureaucrtic systems of managege laefe populations. He chapter on The Examination is essential reading for anyone who has ever taken a test. I think that D&P is one of the immortal works of political philosophy, up there with Capital and Mill's On Liberty and Hobbes' Leviathan and Rousseau's Social Contract and Rawls' Theory of Justice.
F's writing is not opaque. It is plain and workmanlike. If there are differences in idiom, bear in mind that he is French. If it is a bit difficult, that is because it is very deep and he struggling to say new and important things. You have to do some work too. He is not as easy to understand as Chomsky, who is not trying to say anything new or deep in politics, but only to remind you of what you already knew.
jks
--- Dennis Perrin <dperrin at comcast.net> wrote:
> > What exactly of Foucault's ideas did you
> > want to know somjething about? He wrote a lot
> about a
> > lot of topics? Was there something in particular
> that
> > puzzled you, or did you want the whole thing inm a
> > paragraph? jks
>
> I don't know much about his ideas to begin with, so
> a specific request is
> pointless. I suppose I want someone to explain F's
> importance in language I
> can understand. I've watched his exchange with
> Chomsky several times, and
> each time F simply lost me. It seems he engaged in a
> form of techno-speak,
> understood by the Smart Ones or those otherwise
> "inside," but to me it
> sounds like verbal wanking.
>
> DP
>
> ___________________________________
>
http://mailman.lbo-talk.org/mailman/listinfo/lbo-talk
__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! SiteBuilder - Free, easy-to-use web site design software http://sitebuilder.yahoo.com