[lbo-talk] Re: The Importance of Choice

uvj at vsnl.com uvj at vsnl.com
Wed Mar 17 08:22:17 PST 2004


Tahir Wood wrote:

Althusser
>is unable to conceive of the subject in any way other than as an effect of
>structure, therefore having no place in his/her thought for agency, will or
>intention, has been made obvious since Althusser's brand of vulgar
>scientistic Leninism became a dominant element in certain benighted
>sections of the left.

Here is what Althusser writes: "For Lenin, the _real_spontaneity, capacity for action, inventiveness and so on, of the 'masses', was to be respected as _the most precious_ aspect of the workers' movement: but at the same time Lenin condemned the 'ideology of spontaneity' (a dangerous ideology) shared by his opponents (populists and 'Social Revolutionaries'), and recognised that the _real_spontaneity of the masses was to be sustained and criticized in the mean time in order to 'liberate' it from the influence of bourgeois ideology." (Althusser's emphasis)

Ulhas



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list