[lbo-talk] Shiavo "Forbidden video"

[snitsnat]

John A was defending you against Dawson's personal insults. He doesn't 
think you're irrational. He doesn't think you're "barkingly irrational". He 
hasn't said anyone's irrational and, in fact, gave a pretty decent 
rendering of what I, at least, thought you'd been talking about.

At 12:49 PM 4/9/2005, Marta Russell wrote:
>>>  I disagree with her, but I have a question for you: If your argument is
>>>  so strong, how come you have to stoop to insults like 'barkingly
>>>  irrational'?
>>>
>>>  Even though I think you're closer to the truth than she is here, you're
>>>  the one who's coming off as irrational.
>>  >      john A
>
>
>Dawson wrote "barkingly irrational" as an adjective to describe me. Do you 
>apply that to all "barking" women or only to me?
>I'd rather be with Alex Cockburn, Ralph Nader, Nat Hentoff and many others 
>who have expressed similar opinions to Tully's and mine any day than 
>you.  I suppose they are all "irrational" to you too.  I am in good company.