[lbo-talk] article idea

Wojtek Sokolowski sokol at jhu.edu
Thu Aug 18 07:36:10 PDT 2005


Marivin:
> I like the perceptive and principled POV about the Gaza pullout posted by
a
> German contributor to Louis Proyect's Marxmail list, as follows:
>
> "...I am not in favor of ethnically pure territories. I have in
> principle nothing against Jews living in Gaza or whereever in the
> world.
>
> The state of Israel should not forcibly remove them from where they
> chose to live.
>
> They should simply have done three things:
> 1. dismantle the fortifications of the settlements (not the houses)
> 2. disarm the settlers
> 3. withdraw all armed forces and police from the Gaza strip and
> thus hand over the administrative authority over _all_ people and
> places in Gaza strip to the Palestinian Authority.
>
> The same applies to the settlements in Westbank.

That, I believe, dove-tails with the Left's position advocating a single, multiethnic and secular state - which imho is a far more sensible solution than the "bantustan" approach favoured by US liberals.

Wojtek



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list