[lbo-talk] MaxSpeak, You Listen!: CORY SI, TOOKIE NO

Wojtek Sokolowski sokol at jhu.edu
Tue Dec 13 13:24:25 PST 2005


Paul:
> In Terri Schaivo's case the state intervened repeatedly to
> prevent her from dying, as was the request of her legally
> empowered agent; her husband.
>
> These issues cannot be viewed in tandem.

Oh yes, they can, both cases have far reaching similarities:

- both involve highly emotional moral dilemmas about termination of a human life - both involve conflicting views on that subject that can be neither reconciled nor dismissed (i.e. a dilemma) - both involve an impossible ethical choice for anyone seriously concerned about the value of human life - both involve an appeal to collective norms, laws and public institutions to resolve that dilemma - in both cases public opinion has been split between the two conflicting views - in both cases the state intervention favoring any if these conflicting views would anger the adherents of the opposing views

and last but not least - both have been turned into media and political circuses by moral entrepreneurs who use them merely as propaganda tools for their political causes.

Wojtek _______________________ DISCLAIMER: Opinions posted by this writer to this forum are solely forms of literary criticism exercised as the First Amendment right, and do not necessarily reflect the author's views or attitudes toward real-life people, including other writers posting to this forum, groups of people, institutions, or events to which the critiqued texts may refer, either explicitly or implicitly. Any statement asserting or implying such views or attitudes on the basis of this writer's opinions posted to this forum is thus unfounded, and may be libelous. ________________________



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list