[lbo-talk] a teacher in trouble, reply to Nathan

Jim Devine jdevine03 at gmail.com
Sun Mar 5 08:38:28 PST 2006


Nathan: >That's a naive view of power, as if a teacher who can undermine or even destroy a student's college prospects with a bad grade has to explicitly threaten anyone. Even if Bennish would never personally use such power, students can't read a teacher's mind to k now whether they will retaliate against an opposing view.


>And the fact is that propaganda is as much in the facts selected as
an argument made. Another propagandist would want to include the "facts" of intelligent design or whatever facts support their political views, and since students have a relatively low base of knowledge, those facts will have a disproportionate effect on forming their own view of the issue. <

this is why it's bad for a student to have the same teacher year after year for all classes. Students deserve to get a variety of propaganda (and that's what teaching is) from a variety of sources. They also get propaganda from their parents or guardians, from TV, from their peers, etc. In the end, it's their responsibility to sort it out. -- Jim Devine / Bust Big Brother Bush! "Everybody gets so much information all day long that they lose their common sense." -- Gertrude Stein



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list