[lbo-talk] Why the French Resistance Is Not the Model for Iraq

Yoshie Furuhashi critical.montages at gmail.com
Fri Nov 24 07:01:51 PST 2006


On 11/23/06, Doug Henwood <dhenwood at panix.com> wrote:
> Meanwhile, today:
> > BAGHDAD (Reuters) - A series of car bombs killed 160 people in a
> > Shi'ite stronghold in Baghdad on Thursday in the bloodiest single
> > attack since the U.S. invasion of 2003.
> >
> > As political leaders scrambled in public to hold Iraqis back from
> > all-out sectarian civil war, they imposed an indefinite curfew on
> > the capital. Police said the six coordinated blasts in the Sadr
> > City slum wounded 257 people, many maimed for life.
> >
> > The blasts came at the same time as gunmen surrounded and fired on
> > the Shi'ite-run Health Ministry in one of the boldest daylight
> > assaults by militants in Baghdad. Mortars later crashed down on a
> > nearby Sunni enclave in an apparent reprisal attack.
> It'd be nice if there were less that, more resistance.

And it would be nice if there were any resistance in the USA! Unlike the French Resistance, who had the Allies that would eventually defeat the Nazis, and unlike the Vietnamese Communists, who enjoyed the support of socialist powers and whose morale must have been at least a little bit lifted by the emergence of powerful anti-war protests in the USA, etc., the Iraqis are essentially on their own.

The attacks in Iraq yesterday looks like attacks on Sadrists, not jut any Sh'is, given the location: Sadr City. Also, the Health Ministry, according to Al Jazeera, is run by the followers of Sadr:

<blockquote><http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/ED577633-0708-4E94-8737-8CE938979358.htm> Baghdad toll exceeds 200

The death toll from a series of bombs in Sadr City, a poor Shia area of Baghdad, has reached 202.

An estimated 250 people were wounded in Thursday afternoon's attacks.

Iraqi police released the new figures on Friday as Baghdadis started to bury their dead.

Doctors had said many of the wounded were seriously injured and unlikely to survive.

Thursday was one of the bloodiest days in the country since the US invasion.

After the blasts the Iraqi government imposed an indefinite curfew on Baghdad and appealed for calm.

State-run television said the government had also closed Baghdad International Airport to commercial flights until further notice.

Ports and the airport in the southern Shia city of Basra would close in protest over the attacks, an official said.

Pull out threat

Muqtada al-Sadr, the young cleric whose Jaish al-Mahdi (Mahdi Army) militia dominates Sadr City, told chanting supporters in a Friday sermon that the most prominent religious figure from the Sunni group must issue an edict demanding an end to the killing of Shia Muslims.

One of al-Sadr's political aides in parliament told Reuters it would pull out of the US-backed national unity government and from parliament if Nuri al-Maliki, the Shia prime minister, went ahead with next week's meeting with George Bush, the US president, in Jordan.

Faleh Hasan Shanshal told Reuters: "We have asked al-Maliki to cancel his meeting with Bush as there is no reason to meet the criminal who is behind terrorism in Iraq.

"We will suspend our membership in parliament and the cabinet if he goes ahead."

The attacks

Six bombs, apparently coordinated, and a mortar blast were used in Thursday's attacks which caused widespread damage.

Armed men also attacked the city's health ministry on Thursday and fought security guards in a gun battle, trapping 2,000 employees inside.

Officials said the toll could rise since many of the dead had been reduced to scattered body parts and not been fully counted.

After dark, there was sporadic gunfire in several districts.

One of the blasts went off at a market, a regular target for Sunni fighters in the sectarian conflict that has killed thousands of people in Iraq. The neighbourhood is a stronghold of the Shia cleric Muqtada al-Sadr.

After the attacks, al-Maliki warned of "the dark hand of conspiracy that is shedding the blood of the innocent" and urged restraint, saying those responsible would be caught.

Leading Shia, Sunni and Kurdish politicians made a joint appeal for calm on Iraqi television.

Ministry raid

Interior ministry sources said five people were wounded at the health ministry building, about 5km from Sadr City.

The attackers fired mortars, rocket-propelled grenades and machine guns into the compound. The ministry is run by followers of al-Sadr.

Hakim al-Zamili, the deputy health minister, was trapped in the building with the employees.

He said: "First, a series of mortars were fired at the building from the nearby Al-Fadhel neighbourhood, and then about 100 masked gunmen holding machine guns attacked.

"The gunmen came in civilian cars and pick-up trucks and started shooting at the building and wounded a number of employees."

The attackers later withdrew after clashes with American and Iraqi security forces.

A health ministry spokesman said: "The gunmen fled as American helicopters and Iraqi armoured vehicles arrived. Employees were [later] able to leave."

The fighting lasted for several hours but the attackers failed to break into the ministry compound.</blockquote>

Only a government that enjoys legitimacy and mass support in the eyes of Iraqis can quell this type of terrorism. It is not possible for the present Iraqi government to become such a government, and it is not possible to build a new one till the occupier leaves. -- Yoshie <http://montages.blogspot.com/> <http://mrzine.org> <http://monthlyreview.org/>



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list