[lbo-talk] Why the French Resistance Is Not the Model for Iraq

Yoshie Furuhashi critical.montages at gmail.com
Fri Nov 24 08:42:32 PST 2006


On 11/23/06, tfast <tfast at yorku.ca> wrote:
> Perhaps it is evidence of the degree to which the US has become a bit player
> in Iraq. It would appear that the resistance has turned from the question
> of the departure of the US to what the post US power configuration will look
> like.

I don't know if any political current in Iraq has gotten that far, but it does look like Washington has come to prize force protection so much that it is possible that large swathes of Iraq are practically vacated. Into the vacuum has stepped the Qaeda tendency. The vacuum is so large that a Qaeda group -- led by an Iraqi-Canadian! -- is now setting up a "training camp" or two, if this NYT article is to be believed:

<blockquote><http://www.nytimes.com/2006/11/24/world/middleeast/24diyala.html> November 24, 2006 Some Fighters in Iraq Adopt New Tactics to Battle U.S. By EDWARD WONG

FORWARD OPERATING BASE CALDWELL, Iraq, Nov. 23 — Sunni Arab militant groups suspected of having ties to Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia have established training camps east of Baghdad that are turning out well-disciplined units willing to fight American forces in set-piece battles, American military commanders said Thursday.

American soldiers fought such units in a pitched battle last week in Turki, a village 25 miles south of this Iraqi Army base in volatile Diyala Province, bordering Iran. At least 72 insurgents and two American officers were killed in more than 40 hours of fighting. American commanders said they called in 12 hours of airstrikes while soldiers shot their way through a reed-strewn network of canals in extremely close combat.

Officers said that in that battle, unlike the vast majority of engagements in Diyala, insurgents stood and fought, even deploying a platoon-size unit that showed remarkable discipline. One captain said the unit was in "perfect military formation."

Insurgents throughout Iraq usually avoid direct confrontation with American troops, preferring to use hit-and-run tactics and melting away at the sight of American armored vehicles.

Lt. Col. Andrew Poppas, commander of the Fifth Squadron, 73rd Cavalry, a unit of the 82nd Airborne Division, said in an interview that the fighters at Turki "were disciplined and well trained, with well-aimed shots."

"We hadn't seen anything like this in years," he said.

The insurgents had built a labyrinthine network of trenches in the farmland, with sleeping areas and weapons caches. Two antiaircraft guns had been hidden away.

Insurgents were apparently able to establish a training camp after American forces moved out of the area in the fall of 2005, Colonel Poppas said. Sunni Arab militants there belong to the fundamentalist Wahhabi strain of Islam and are believed to be led, at least in part, by a man known as Abu Abdul Rahman, an Iraqi-Canadian who moved from Canada to Iraq in 1995 after marrying a woman from Turki, he said.

Abu Abdul Rahman was mentioned on some jihadist Web sites as a possible contender for the leadership of Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia after the group's founder, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, was killed in an American airstrike in Diyala Province in June, said Capt. Mike Few, commander of A Troop, Fifth Squadron.

Senior commanders training Iraqi Army units here say other rural areas of eastern and central Diyala where American forces have had little oversight have been transformed into camps similar to the one at Turki. The "graduates," many of whom belong to an umbrella group called the Sunni Council, then spread to urban areas like Baquba, the provincial capital, said Maj. Tim Sheridan, an intelligence officer. Sectarian violence is rampant in Diyala, where Sunni and Shiite militants are vying for control.

The battle at Turki began after Colonel Poppas and other soldiers flew over the area on a reconnaissance mission on Nov. 12. From the helicopters, they spotted a white car covered by shrubbery and a hole in the ground that appeared to be a hiding place. The colonel dropped off an eight-man team and later sent other soldiers to sweep the area.

Gunfire erupted on Nov. 15 when one unit ran into an ambush. The fighting eventually became so intense that the Americans called in airstrikes. An American captain and a lieutenant, both West Point graduates, were killed by insurgents in separate firefights.</blockquote>

Saddam Hussein would never have tolerated things like that. -- Yoshie <http://montages.blogspot.com/> <http://mrzine.org> <http://monthlyreview.org/>



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list