[lbo-talk] Harry Potter, Metritocracy, and Reward

Carl Remick carlremick at hotmail.com
Sun Aug 26 06:01:23 PDT 2007



>From: andie nachgeborenen <andie_nachgeborenen at yahoo.com>
>
>Carl, what makes you the arbiter of who is entitled to
>be on the left? I don't like poverty (for anyone), I
>want to be able to send my kids to college (and
>everyone to do so), and I do like middle class
>material comfort (for everyone), so I'm not ascetic
>enough to be a leftist? I like to get some respect for
>the work that I do, so I'm a bad guy right wing
>scumbag? And I'm hearing this from a guy who made a
>living as a career PR flack for the same bad-guy
>corporations I used to defend? Are we back in fuck-you
>territory, Carl? Yeah, I was a bad-guy corpo lawyer,
>but you are hardly in a position to get ethically up
>on a high horse. Anyway, I'm a college professor now,
>or is that bad too?

If you're dispensing the same nonsense to your students that you do to this list, I would have to say, yes, your influence is probably more malign now that you're back in the classroom than it was when you were a bad-guy corpo lawyer. I will say this for my experience as a PR flack, it cemented my awareness that the capitalist system is deeply, intrinsically evil and needs to be torn out root and branch. I state that message unequivocally and repeatedly on this list. Meanwhile, you seem to bounce merrily back and forth between academe and corporate lawyerdom, simply deepening your complacent conceit that the system just needs a little tweaking and all will be dandy.

I can't decide whether you're more preposterous in your role as philosopher king or legal eagle. In either case, your writing style is terminally turgid and your thoughts mere cloud formations. I don't for a minute believe that you are a socialist of any kind but simply a pompous parvenu who delights in gloating about his wardrobe of expensive Italian leatherwear.

But please don't let me drive you from this list. I treasure your presence here as an inexhaustible source of laughs.

Carl

_________________________________________________________________ Now you can see trouble…before he arrives http://newlivehotmail.com/?ocid=TXT_TAGHM_migration_HM_viral_protection_0507



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list