[lbo-talk] Reasons to be cheerful

Dennis Redmond dredmond at efn.org
Wed Feb 28 23:24:12 PST 2007


FDK wrote:


> The European Union is *NOT* a project of human
> liberation!

Nonsense. There are many fine things to admire about the EU: its social charter, its powerful unions and mighty social movements, MC Solaar, a multinational parliament, the world's largest development bank, IG Metall, Green parties, 50 million immigrants, the videogames of Crytek and Remedy, Heiner Mueller, the Taz... all part of the EU.


> It's an insult to refugees who
> are literally dying to get into the fortress, to the
> politically marginalized groups subject to increased
> repression at the hands of the state, and to the
> Eastern Europe periphery.

The EU takes in 1.2 million immigrants every year; those politically marginalized groups are fighting back through new types of cultural and political mobilization; and Eastern Europe is a thriving semi-periphery with very interesting class struggles.


> And you depict yourself as
> something of an Adorno epigone. Perhaps the Adorno
> who called the police on demonstrating students.
> Certainly not the Adorno of _Reflexionen zur
> Klassentheorie_.

It's not productive to judge the lifelong output of a thinker on the basis of one short-sighted or misguided decision.

-- DRR



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list