This formulation is all wrong from the jump. I think what Carrol was trying to say was that in America, a "fascist" movement, whatever that might be, would come through a pleasing, uplifting, hopefully entertaining figure, rather than from a stern moralist who goosesteps. Gore Vidal pegged this decades ago, saying that an American dictator would be more Arthur Godfrey and less Douglas Macarthur. Vidal thought that Reagan was that figure, but then, that puts personality ahead of system.
Dennis