[lbo-talk] Chazelle: Jury Duty Democracy

c b cb31450 at gmail.com
Mon Aug 24 09:40:32 PDT 2009


Michael Pollak :

By: Bernard Chazelle

I suggest that all US senators and representatives should be picked at

random among the adult population.

^^^^^^^^

This sounds a little like Borges' short story.

Charles

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lottery_in_Babylon

The Lottery in Babylon

"The Babylon Lottery" Author Jorge Luis Borges Original title "La lotería en Babilonia"

The Babylon Lottery (original Spanish title: La lotería en Babilonia) is a fantasy short story by Argentine writer Jorge Luis Borges. It first appeared in 1941 in the journal Sur, and then was included in the 1941 collection The Garden of Forking Paths (El jardín de senderos que se bifurcan), before being included in Ficciones, part one. The title also appears as The Lottery in Babylon.

[edit] Plot summary It describes a fictional society in ancient Babylon in which all activities are dictated by an all-encompassing lottery, a metaphor for the role of chance in one's life. Initially, the lottery was run as a modern lottery would be with tickets purchased and the winner receiving a financial reward. Then, it had the usual material rewards; later, punishments and immaterial rewards were introduced. Further, there was no need to voluntarily participate. Finally, it simultaneously became so all-encompassing and so secret that no one could tell whether the lottery still exists to alter people's fates, or whether the world runs blindly or by chance.

A further interpretation is that the Lottery and the Company that runs it are actually an allegory of a deity or God. Like the workings of a deity in the eyes of men, the Company that runs the Lottery acts, apparently, at random and through means not known by its subjects, leaving men with two options: to accept it to be all-knowing and all-powerful but mysterious, or to deny its existence. Both theories have supporters in this allegory.

In many other books, Borges dealt with metaphysical questions about the meaning of life and the possible existence of higher authorities, and also presented this same paradoxical vision of a world that may be run by a good and wise deity but seems to lack any discernible meaning. This view may also be considered present in The Library of Babel, another Borges story.

Borges makes a brief reference to Franz Kafka as Qaphqa, the legendary Latrine where spies of the Company leave information.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list