Religious Jews have done the same thing to secular Jews throughout the ages, and vice-versa.
> If it's not obvious, the practice by non-Jews of
> instructing Jews on
> how to be good Jews is anti-semitic, or at the very least
> pretty
> repugnant. The practice of attacking secular Jews for not
> being
> religious is an old anti-semitic canard. It's a way of
> questioning
> the identity of Jews. The identity of Jews is to have no
> identity, or
> to have some kind of malign covert identity. Jews are bad
> because
> they are not Jewish enough.
>
> The fairness of the quote remains to be seen, I agree.
>
> mbs
>
>