[lbo-talk] Agency and Capitalism

Angelus Novus fuerdenkommunismus at yahoo.com
Thu Dec 30 13:49:17 PST 2010


I just stumbled across this (rather old) blog post and I think it has something to say regarding recent discussion threads on this list concerning Wikileaks, capitalism, the "ruling class" as oligarchy, capital having "names and addresses", etc.

Excerpt from: <http://k-punk.abstractdynamics.org/archives/007709.html>

"That ontological dimension in what is missing from the progressive populist model, in which the masses cannot but appear as a dupes, fooled by the lies of the elite but ready to effectuate change the moment they are made aware of the truth. The reality, of course, is that the 'masses' are under few illusions about the ruling elite (if anyone is credulous about politicians and 'capitalist parliamentarianism', it is the middle classes). The Subject Supposed Not To Know is a figure of populist fantasies - more than that: the duped subject awaiting factual enlightenment is the presupposition on which progressive populism rests. If the most crucial political task is to enlighten the masses about the venality of the ruling class, then the preferred mode of discourse will be denunciation. Yet, this repeats rather than challenges the logic of the liberal order; it is no accident that the Mail and the Express favour the same denunciatory mode. Attacks on

politicians tend to reinforce the atmosphere of diffuse cynicism upon which capitalist realism feeds. What is needed is not more empirical evidence of the evils of the ruling class but a belief on the part of the subordinate class that what they think or say matters; that they are the only effective agents of change.

This returns us to the question of reflexive impotence. Class power has always depended on a kind of reflexive impotence, with the subordinate class's beliefs about its own incapacity for action reinforcing that very condition. It would, of course, be grotesque to blame the subordinate class for their subordination; but to ignore the role that their complicity with the existing order plays in a self-fulfilling circuit would, ironically, be to deny their power."

<End Excerpt>

This reminds me of a brilliant sticker by the group Gender Killer I once saw on a lamppost: "Capitalism is Not a Conspiracy of the Few. It Works Because You Work."



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list