[lbo-talk] Philip Mirowski - Social Physicist

default egwinslow at rogers.com
Fri Mar 5 06:06:44 PST 2010


Vincent Clarke wrote:


> Lacan contends that in people suffering from psychosis have
> failed to integrate the structures of their particular culture
> properly

On this understanding of psychosis, there's no basis for judging psychotic perception delusional.

There's also no basis for judging anyone as psychotic since this requires knowledge of reality, namely, knowledge of the reality of "the structures of their particular culture" and of the "structure" of the person who is the object of the judgment. Reality, however, is an unknowable thing in itself where perception is determined by "structures" in this sense.

The only relation this can have to psychoanalysis in any reasonable sense is that such a psychoanalysis might be able to explain the psychopathology involved, a psychopathology characteristic of the "particular culture" in which it's widespread.

Ted



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list