Why? Some years ago, an Oakland man beat his three year old boy to death because the toddler could not be made to read. The consesus was that the father was a monster. But those who should know better now tell us that five year olds should learn to read English. I don't deny some can. But the vast majority cannot and should not. And because they are made to, as a matter of policy, they are likely to think of themselves as failures and incapable of learning, starting at the age of five.
There is then also a lot of institutional monstrosity.
Joanna
----- Original Message -----