[lbo-talk] The closing of American academia

Wojtek S wsoko52 at gmail.com
Tue Aug 21 04:38:31 PDT 2012


http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2012/08/2012820102749246453.html

In most professions, salaries below the poverty line would be cause for alarm. In academia, they are treated as a source of gratitude. Volunteerism is par for the course - literally. Teaching is touted as a "calling", with compensation an afterthought. One American research university offers its PhD students a salary of $1000 per semester for the "opportunity" to design and teach a course for undergraduates, who are each paying about $50,000 in tuition. The university calls this position "Senior Teaching Assistant" because paying an instructor so far below minimum wage is probably illegal.

In addition to teaching, academics conduct research and publish, but they are not paid for this work either. Instead, all proceeds go to for-profit academic publishers, who block academic articles from the public through exorbitant download and subscription fees, making millions for themselves in the process. If authors want to make their research public, they have to pay the publisher an average of $3000 per article. Without an institutional affiliation, an academic cannot access scholarly research without paying, even for articles written by the scholar itself.

It may be hard to summon sympathy for people who walk willingly into such working conditions. "Bart, don't make fun of grad students," Marge told her son on an oft-quoted episode of The Simpsons. "They just made a terrible life choice."

[WS:] On the top of it, the process of getting an academic job is like a beauty contest - those without inside connections need not apply.

This makes one wonder why so many people (including myself) are still attracted to this job market? Is it because it is a consequence of the brainwashing touting academic work as a "calling" as she claims? Or is it because the alternatives suck even more?

-- Wojtek

"An anarchist is a neoliberal without money."



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list