Is Buchanan an antisemite?

Martin Schiller mart555 at
Sun Nov 21 13:38:40 PST 1999

Nathan Newman said on 11/21/99 9:50 AM

>Actually, the first place to start is to distinguish anti-Zionism from being
>anti-Jewish (dropping the "semite" peoples debate). A lot of folks think
>Israel is illegitimate, but that does not make them anti-Jewish.

Your distinction is accepted and hence the term that I will ask for distinction regarding will be "anti-jewish". And though your analysis of Buchanan provides further weight to his credentials as both a jew-baiter and a rabble-rouser it provides no clue as to the distinction between a buchanan and his roused-rabble regarding the application of the term "anti-jewish" to their respective activities.


More information about the lbo-talk mailing list