Hate crimes

Jim heartfield jim at heartfield.demon.co.uk
Fri Oct 15 17:25:26 PDT 1999


In message <s8074717.044 at mail.ci.detroit.mi.us>, Charles Brown <CharlesB at CNCL.ci.detroit.mi.us> writes
>-clip-
>I'd appreciate any additional materials the might be
>helpful for either myself or students in regards to this
>issue. What is hate speech? What are the limits of
>freedom? What is justice?

May I immodestly recommend my own article 'Why Hate Speech?'

http://www.informinc.co.uk/LM/LM107/LM107_Speech.html

Nadine Strossen was kind enough to tell that it could not be bested as an argument for freedom of speech.

I was talking to my niece who has just started at Secondary School at age 11, and she showed me her exercise books which have an advertisement from the Commission for Racial Equality on them. Intrigued I asked her whether racism was a problem at her school. Oh yes, she said solemnly, we have had an assembly all about it. And are there many racists there, I pressed. Well she said, there is this one boy, who was singled out in the assembly. He mutters racist epithets under his breath in the classroom and shouts them at people in the playground.

Really? I said. Yes, she replied. His father is black, and left his mother - he blames black people. Maybe you would be a bit disturbed if you were in his position, I suggested. Oh, no, she said, all proper, I would not mind at all if my father was black.

My stomach turned at the thought of the headmaster lecturing his pupils about the problem of racism by singling out one mixed race child, who is plainly disturbed. But of course, this is how anti-racism works in Britain. A couple of months ago, Greenwich police inaugurated a big anti-racist initiative. Amongst the dangerous race criminals arrested a black schoolgirl who, with her friends had been bothering an elderly neighbour. Because the neighbour is of a different race (ie white) the police noted the 'crime' as a race crime. Embarrassed to be caught leading away a dangerous criminal in a school uniform, the police protested that they had decided against a dawn raid and waited till she got up.

-- Jim heartfield



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list