eco-optimism

Ian Murray seamus2001 at home.com
Fri Aug 10 13:24:59 PDT 2001


A cup of
> tea and solidarity....
>
> ((((((((
>
> CB: In the case of socialism/communism , I think the role active
ruling class opposition in the forms of biggest wars ever, fascism, McCarthyism, Gramscian hegmonic operations, myriad of other anti-communist methods has blocked mass consciousness more than general lack of smartness, as contrasted with barriers to advancing physics. ======== That was totally true in the past, yes. It seems the challenges for us now are very Gramscian; creating and placing the best ideas we have for land use, organizational accountability and participation, health care access, investment policies, debt eradication, logistics for food distribution, education, demilitarization...the big grocery list for a better world. At the same time we have to acknowledge human limitations and come to a better understanding of why many want to perpetuate 'dog-eat-dog' competitiveness as the optimal form of social dynamics and organization. That is, we have to take up G A Cohen's challenge in the 'Withering away of Social Science':

"Being social animals, exploiters have to feel that their social behavior is justifiable. When the feeling is difficult to reconcile with the truth, the truth must be hidden from them as well as from those they oppress. Illusion is therefore constitutive of class societies."

While theory alone won't do it, if we don't have the ideas of robustly thought out alternatives so as to undo the mirage-like character of capitalism, then fellow citizens aren't likely to mobilize to change it for the better. The past 24 months have seen more citizens take up the challenge in Cohen's statement since, perhaps, the fall of the Berlin Wall, and calls to mind the 'graffiti' on the BW: "Next Time it Will Be Better". That statement calls for much humility, imo.


>
> On the struggle as the thing, in the early 1900's there had never
even been socialist revolutions anywhere, and thus the general sense of the realistic possibility of socialist revolution probably was not higher than today. Yet , Lenin counselled in opposition to Bernstein's " the movement is everything, the final goal nothing" that "without revolutionary theory , there can be no revolutionary movement" In other words, even today, when it seems the best we can do is just "struggle", we may better strive to make a big plan and strategize =========== Totally agree. At the same time we need to understand that egalitarianism and non-authoritarianism is not consistent with vanguardism of any kind.

Ian



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list