zionism

Brad DeLong delong at econ.Berkeley.EDU
Fri Jul 13 10:57:11 PDT 2001



>It seems to me that framing this discussion as "what do we want,
>peace or justice?" misses the point. If an injustice has been done
>to me, it may be wise for me to settle for a limited remedy of the
>injustice simply because the costs of extending a conflict (through
>the courts, for example) to remedy the injustice can come to exceed
>the harm done me by the initial injustice. On the other hand, since
>the costs of pursuing a conflict of this sort are usually
>irretrievable, it may be rational for me to continue to pursue the
>conflict even if my costs have already exceeded any possible gain.
>BUT: I am the one who gets to decide when it is in my interest to
>forego the conflict, and to settle for peace instead of justice.
>Least of all does someone who has been bankrolling the party who has
>done me the injustice get to lecture me about my irrationality in
>refusing "half a loaf".
>
>Michael McIntyre

I don't by the "no one else has standing to talk about it" line. We all have standing to discuss what people *should* do.

Brad DeLong



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list