Arguments for ground war - forget it

Brad DeLong jbdelong at uclink.berkeley.edu
Mon Nov 19 06:29:13 PST 2001



>>>Of course the war was not legitimate. Of course in a world in
>>>which there are such inequalities of wealth and power, a
>>>counterattack was illegitimate.
>>
>>So we should have gone to visit the homes of the dishwashers at
>>Windows on the World killed on September 11, and told their wives,
>>husbands, and children that "Because the United States is a rich
>>and powerful country, it would be illegitimate to take any steps to
>>force the Taliban to hand over those responsible for this atrocity,
>>and illegitimate to take any steps to reduce Al-Qaeda's ability to
>>commit a similar atrocity again?"
>>
>>Somehow I don't think so.
>>
>>Brad DeLong
>
>I doubt that anyone, whether s/he is for or against the war, has
>visited "the homes of the dishwashers at Windows on the World,"
>except some of their kin, friends, neighbors, & perhaps bill
>collectors.
>--
>Yoshie

Relief and aid workers...



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list