Bin Laden: The story that needs to be told

Jeffrey Fisher jfisher at igc.org
Wed Sep 12 22:13:30 PDT 2001


credit where credit's due -- i just saw a pretty good report on nightline/abcnews on the threats and harassment being borne by muslims and arab-americans in the aftermath of tuesday. the flip-side, of course, is that the outpouring of hatred on which they were reporting is staggering.

also saw peter jennings earlier highlighting the need to understand the systemic nature of what happened. he was trying to point out that a military response (alone) would not solve the problem.

i think also that the coverage has changed since yesterday. not scientific, but aside from an appalling (imo) suntimes editorial today (9/12), i believe i haven't seen reports of palestinian celebrations getting the same play--or being deployed as much in the same way--today as they did yesterday. they were slow to blame arabs, but they were very quick to jump on those images, despite oklahoma city.


> From: "Nathan Newman" <nathan at newman.org>
> Reply-To: lbo-talk at lists.panix.com
> Date: Wed, 12 Sep 2001 20:22:09 -0400
> To: <lbo-talk at lists.panix.com>
> Subject: Re: Bin Laden: The story that needs to be told
>
> On the other hand, ABC ran a tremendously good report noting the bitterness
> of Palestinians because of US support for Israel, our support for their
> dominance of Islamic holy sites, and the use of American weapons in killing
> Palestinians - all with visuals of suffering Palestinians - in noting the
> support at times in the region for the bombing. They combined this with a
> long story on the anti-Arab and anti-Islam threats against Americans from
> the region and noted that there were doubtless many Arab and Islamic
> Americans who died in the bombing, just like other Americans.
>
> Frankly, the media has been quite good in repeatedly condemning any hint of
> backlash against Arab and Islamic Americans. They've given lots of play to
> Guiliani's surprisingly moving defense of tolerance and refusal to give into
> hate (it makes you think he should have gotten cancer years ago; he's become
> such a liberal softie.)
>
> I think at least some of the media are doing penance for their wrong racist
> reactions to the Oklahoma City bombings.
>
> Nathan
> nathan at newman.org
> http://www.nathannewman.org
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "Chris Kromm" <ckromm at mindspring.com>
> To: <lbo-talk at lists.panix.com>
> Sent: Wednesday, September 12, 2001 8:09 PM
> Subject: Re: Bin Laden: The story that needs to be told
>
>
> Luke,
>
> In your zeal to make a point, you're dead wrong. Many, many news accounts --
> and I've been watching many -- have omitted the story of bin Laden's CIA
> connection. Stratfor's intelligence briefing on bin Laden -- widely
> circulated, quoted and posted on official news websites -- left out any
> reference of the Cold War context, CIA backing, or U.S. involvement on any
> level.
>
> Your doting words towards mainstream media accounts are bizarre. Media
> coverage has been wrong on this, and other issues. And it's important that
> they are called on it.
>
> Chris
>
>
> Date: Wed, 12 Sep 2001 17:23:33 -0400
> From: lweiger at umich.edu
> Subject: Re: Bin Laden: The story that needs to be told
>
>>>
>>> You assume that it hasn't already been told loud and clear. My father
>>> told me that one of the major news anchors was discussing it with an
>>> analyst last night. Who could forget that just yesterday the Soviets
>>> were fighting the US-backed Taliban?
>>>
>>> -- Luke
>>
>> It certainly hasn't been emphasized in any coverage I've seen. Plenty of
>> people in the U.S. have forgotten, or never knew. And when they were
>> fighting the Soviets, they were generally known in the west as the
>> "mujahadeen" or just Afghan rebels. I don't know how generally it's
>> understood that the "Taliban" are (many of) the same people. So yes, it
>> is still our job (and anyone's who cares) to make sure this is talked
>> about.
>>
>> Gary Ashwill
>
> And, as I noted, apparently even major news anchors like Dan Rather are
> willing to note the historical context. There is no "mainstream media"
> demonically attempting to spin reality away (even though, of course, this
> analysis is likely to be more prominently featured in the Nation than
> Newsweek).
>
> - -- Luke
>
>
>
>



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list