Reasons to support war on Iraq

Ulhas Joglekar uvj at vsnl.com
Sat Feb 8 18:16:42 PST 2003


Alexandre Fenelon wrote:
>> I am not sure if the US will be weakened by war on Iraq. How is this
going
>> to happen?


> 1-The USA economy had a poor performance last year, despite massive
> incentives (the analogy with early 90´s Japan comes to my mind). I
> believe that imperial adventures are costly and the USA can´t afford
> them in the current situation (and, unlike what happen in the first
> Gulf war, Japan, Europe and Arab countries are not going to pay the
> bill, I hope)

Cost estimates depend on various scenarios. I don't know much about the US economy, but Stiglitz estimates the cost of Iraq war at about 0.1 or 0.2 % of the US GDP. Is this beyond the capacity of the US economy?


> 3-Unlike the other wars, we will have the USA troops making the dirty
> job of invasion/occupation, which can led to a relatively prolonged war.

After the fall Baghdad, the US could hand over the law and order to the UN.


> -What is the price the world pays for continued US hegemony?

What is the state of Afghanistan today after the Soviet occupation and the US response to it? It's a disaster for Afghans and their neighbours.


>> Even if this were to happen, it might strengthen Islamic fundamentalism
in
>> West Asia in the medium term. I don't see the Left growing in Asia in the
>. coming period.


> -That are legitimate concerns. But I don´t know to contain Islamic
> -fundamentalism. The US fed the beast in the last 30 years and now
> -are unable to deal with her, because, in a certain way, they are
> -fundamentalist too. And I doubt if war or its absence will help
> -the left to grow in Asia. That´s another question.

There are about 400 million Muslims in South Asia. Islamic fundamentalism and its Hindu counterpart is the most important threat to democracy and secularism in South Asia.

Ulhas



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list