you are new here, right? because Carrol has a long, long antipathy to Pug, Newman, and now apparently, Dawson. As well as the Weathermen. Placing them all on the same order as provacateurs is horseshit and I don't find your defense of his comments especially compelling. And, although I love Carrol and very much admire and respect him -- I'm not sure why my post elicited the Pope-like ex cathedra lecture.
Where exactly in anything I wrote was I caterwauling about this terrain? I was trying to bring some understanding to T Brown's comments, putting them in context. I wasn't denouncing Chruchill _or_ Thomas. So, why does my post elicit the concern that I'm caterwauling about some terrain I just can't deal with.
As for the rest, I believe I already addressed this in my response to him AND yoshie. Anything new to add? Scratch that. I'm bitchy and I'm disgusted by the refusal to see how harmful it is to even suggest that newman or pugliese or dawson are provacateurs or should be characterized as deserving to sit in the same textual space. There was an equivalence made there that is truly disturbing to me and it should be to everyone else it.
It's not? So fuckin' be it.
kelley
>Rather, there are all different sorts of
>bumps and dips on the landscape, and there will ALWAYS
>be. And if the "left" gains ground in any substantive
>way, I think we can expect more of a variegated
>terrain, not less.
>
>Those who speak and operate in any of these contexts
>are not saints sent by God in Heaven to deliver a
>Message. The people we hear from, and the ideas they
>express at any given time are the results of
>historico-material circumstances. If they are
>delivering a message some find embarassing, repulsive,
>etc., we should not be sitting around scratching our
>heads.
>
>--adx
>
>=====
>"Mary Poppins is alive and well in Argentina, she sends her regards."
>- Rod McKuen, The Mud Kids
>
>
>
>__________________________________
>Do you Yahoo!?
>All your favorites on one personal page Try My Yahoo!
>http://my.yahoo.com
>___________________________________
>http://mailman.lbo-talk.org/mailman/listinfo/lbo-talk
"We live under the Confederacy. We're a podunk bunch of swaggering pious hicks."
--Bruce Sterling