-----Original Message-----
>From: Marv Gandall <marvgand at gmail.com>
>> And this applies only to Jordan? You've seemed absolutely confident yourself.
>
>Not when it comes to dispensing advice about what those engaged in strikes, campaigns, and various kinds of political activity ought or ought not to do. Many of us have learned from our own experience that things can look very different from the inside than the outside, so so I try to be avoid rushing to judgement about whether their actions are irrelevant, counter-productive, a diversion, strategically wrong, a betrayal, etc.
Nobody said anything about that except you. I haven't seen anyone giving that kind of advice, only questioning assumptions.